A German home-appliance OEM needed a 2.1 mm appliance fascia with a matte VDI 3400 texture that stayed clean after handling. We moved the texture reference to the tool steel, cut gloss from 12 to 4 units at 60°, and held 0.06 mm flatness across a 385 mm span.
Key takeaways
- Fingerprint visibility is a gloss problem, not a colour problem. Dropping 60° gloss below 5 units removes most of the effect.
- VDI 3400 texture is cut into the steel, so the part releases the exact negative of it. Photo-etched depth must be specified in µm, not by a visual sample alone.
- Every texture adds a draft penalty. A VDI 27 etch on a 2.1 mm wall needs 1.5° per side of additional draft at the corners, or ejection scuffs the surface.
- Glass-filled resin imprints texture differently from unfilled resin. The same etch reads 2–3 units duller on a 20% glass grade.
- Texture is a maintenance item. It is polished back between production runs, and the number of polishes a cavity will take should be settled before the steel order.
The challenge
A German appliance OEM asked us to quote a front fascia for a built-in oven control panel. The part is the first thing a buyer touches in a showroom, so the surface has to survive a decade of kitchen handling without showing it.
The geometry was not the problem. The part is a single-curved shell, 385 × 210 mm, nominal wall 2.1 mm, with two recesses for the display window and a 12 mm return flange on all four sides. Mold making is straightforward in this envelope.
The surface was the problem. The customer’s existing supplier delivered parts with a VDI 3400 reference 27 texture that measured 11–13 gloss units at 60°. Within a week of handling in their test kitchen, the fascia showed a visible fingerprint pattern around the control knob and along the top edge where thumbs rest.
Their constraints were tight and they were explicit about them. Wall thickness stayed at 2.1 mm because the electronics stack behind it was already frozen. Resin stayed ABS/PC because the part needed to pass a 1.2 m drop test and a 90 °C heat-age at 500 hours. The texture reference could not exceed VDI 27, because anything coarser broke the printed graphic alignment in the window recess. And the tool budget was capped at 28,000 USD with a 7-week T1 requirement.
They had already run two tooling attempts with another supplier. The first tool produced a texture that read correct on a visual plaque but ran 6 units too glossy on the part. The second tool hit the gloss target but scuffed on ejection at the four corners, which left bright rub marks that were more visible than the fingerprints had been.
What we did
We broke the problem into two independent variables: the optical result (gloss and texture read) and the mechanical result (release without scuffing). Treating them as one variable is what sank the previous two tools.
Step 1: measure the gloss spec, not the texture plaque
We asked for the customer’s handling photos and measured the existing parts on a 60° gloss meter at nine points. The reading was 11.4 units average, with a 3.2 unit spread between the flat face and the curved return flange. That spread mattered more than the average: the fingerprint was most visible in the flange, where the surface was glossiest.
We set the target at 4 units ±1 at 60° on the flat face and 5 units ±1 on the flange, and we specified both numbers in the drawing. A single number would have let the toolmaker optimise the face and leave the flange shiny.
Step 2: cut the texture into hardened steel before final polish
The cavity block is 1.2343 (H11) ESR, hardened to 48–52 HRC before texture work. We specified the etch as VDI 3400 reference 30 with a 18 µm etch depth, applied by acid etch rather than by bead blast, because blast depth varies with operator pressure and the customer needed a repeatable number for a second tool.
Reference 30 is one step coarser than the customer’s original reference 27. That is deliberate. Coarser etch removes more specular reflection, and we compensated the print window recess with a masked polish so the graphic alignment zone stayed at reference 24.
Two steel coupons were etched first and shot in a short trial before the cavity was committed. The coupons confirmed 4.1 units on unfilled ABS/PC at the specified mold temperature, so we cut the production cavity.
Step 3: pay for the texture with draft
Texture depth forces draft. Our rule on this part was 1.5° per side of extra draft on top of the geometric minimum, which put the wall draft at 3.0° per side on the long edges and 3.5° at the four corners.
The customer’s original CAD had 1.0° on the long edges and 1.2° on the corners. We sent a DFM report in 3 working days that flagged the four corners as a release failure waiting to happen, and proposed re-drafting the corner radii from R6 to R9 so the draft could be added without moving the display window datum.
That single change is what eliminated the scuff marks the previous supplier had fought. Texture does not scuff on a flat wall that opens cleanly; it scuffs where the part has to slide across the etch before it releases.
Step 4: control the mold temperature to fix the gloss
Gloss on a textured ABS/PC part is a function of how faithfully the melt copies the etch. Cold melt freezes before it reaches the bottom of the texture, which reads glossier because the fine peaks round off.
We ran the tool on a hot-water unit at 82 °C cavity and 78 °C core, with a 9 °C core-cavity differential to keep the visible face hotter than the hidden side. Cycle came in at 34 seconds, with 12 seconds of cooling, 6 seconds of hold, and a 2-stage ejection.
First shots measured 6.2 units on the face. We raised cavity temperature to 88 °C and extended cool by 2 seconds, which brought the reading to 4.0 units and held it across 40 shots.
Step 5: define the texture maintenance life in the tool design
A textured cavity is a consumable surface. Each polish-back removes 2–3 µm and slightly dulls the etch, so the gloss drifts upward over the tool’s life.
We designed the cavity so the texture could be re-etched twice without losing the print window datum, and we wrote a 250,000-shot polish interval into the tool documentation. For a part at 8,000 units a month, that is roughly two and a half years between texture refreshes.
The result
The tool reached T1 on day 41, inside the 7-week window. The first trial shot hit the gloss target on the second temperature adjustment, and no corner scuffing appeared on any shot.
The table below compares the customer’s original condition against the delivered result.
| Parameter | Previous supplier | RCH Plastic result |
|---|---|---|
| Texture reference (VDI 3400) | 27 | 30 face / 24 window recess |
| Etch depth | 11 µm, blast | 18 µm, acid etch |
| 60° gloss, flat face | 11.4 units | 4.0 units ±1 |
| 60° gloss, return flange | 14.6 units | 4.8 units ±1 |
| Gloss spread across part | 3.2 units | 0.8 units |
| Wall draft | 1.0° / 1.2° corner | 3.0° / 3.5° corner |
| Corner radius | R6 | R9 |
| Cavity temperature | 62 °C | 88 °C |
| Cycle time | 31 s | 34 s |
| Ejection scuff rejects | 6.4% | 0.3% |
| Fingerprint visibility after 7-day handling | visible, score 3/5 | faint, score 1/5 |
| Flatness over 385 mm | 0.14 mm | 0.06 mm |
| Tool delivery to T1 | 58 days | 41 days |
The handling test is the number the customer cared about most. Seven days of simulated kitchen use, with 40 touch cycles a day on ungloved hands, took the fascia from a visible print pattern to a faint one that only showed at grazing light.
The trade was 3 seconds of cycle time. That is the honest cost of running a textured tool hot: 3 seconds per shot on a 34-second cycle is about 9% of machine time, which at 8,000 units a month is roughly 6.7 extra machine hours. Against a 6.4% reject rate on scuffing and a surface the customer could not sell, the trade is not close.
Flatness also improved, from 0.14 mm to 0.06 mm, because the higher mold temperature reduced the frozen-in stress that had been pulling the return flange out of plane.
What carries to your project
Five principles from this project apply to almost any textured cosmetic part, whatever the appliance.
1. Specify gloss, not just a VDI number
VDI 3400 describes the etch, not the result. The same reference reads differently on unfilled and glass-filled resin, and differently again at different mold temperatures. Put a gloss number at 60° on the drawing, with a tolerance and a measurement location.
2. Budget draft for the texture, not for the geometry
Add 1.5° per side for a medium etch and 2° for a coarse one. If the part cannot take that draft, the texture is the wrong choice and a film or in-mold label will serve better.
3. Etch coupons before committing the cavity
Two etched steel coupons shot in a short trial cost a few hundred dollars and settle the gloss question before 28,000 USD of steel is cut. Ask your toolmaker for this step explicitly; it is not standard practice.
4. Run the tool hot and accept the cycle cost
A textured cosmetic part wants a mold at 80–90 °C. Planning for a 30-second cycle on a textured tool and getting 34 seconds is normal; planning for 30 and getting scuffs is not.
5. Write the texture maintenance interval into the tool file
Ask how many polish-backs the cavity will take and what each one costs in gloss. A tool that loses its texture in year two is a tool that will be replaced in year four.
Our answer on textured cosmetic parts
Our answer: RCH Plastic reference for textured cosmetic parts is to treat the surface as a controlled process, not a finish option. We cut texture into hardened 1.2343 (H11) ESR steel at 48–52 HRC, specify etch depth in µm, and verify gloss on a 60° meter at nine points before the tool leaves for trial.
The reason we can hold this is structural. We do mold making in-house, molding through vetted partners, so the tool and the process parameters are ours to iterate together. When a textured tool needs a 6 °C temperature change to hit a gloss target, we do not have to negotiate that with a third party.
The evidence we hand over at trial is the same set on every textured part: the sample, trial photographs, trial video, a full process parameter sheet, and a CMM dimensional report traceable to the tool number. CMM reports confirm the flatness number; the gloss meter reading confirms the surface. Both go in the file.
For a textured appliance part above 100,000 units a year, the tool will be re-etched at least once inside its life. Plan the texture budget at quoting stage rather than at the first polish.
Related guides in this series
- Injection Molding Texture and VDI 3400 Roughness
- Injection Molding Defects and Quality Guide
- Mold Design and DFM Guide
- Injection Molding Draft Angle: How Much Draft
- Injection Mold Surface Finish: SPI and VDI Comparison
- Case Study: Heat Sink Housing, Conductive Fill vs Unfilled PA66
- Injection Molding Materials Guide
If you are quoting a textured cosmetic part and want the gloss target settled before the steel is ordered, send us your CAD and a photo of the current parts. A DFM report with the draft and texture recommendation comes back in 3 working days, at no cost.
